To address the issue, he called for social policies to restrict immigration and prohibit racial mixing. A few years before, American psychologist and education researcher Lewis Terman had drawn connections between intellectual ability and race.
In , he wrote:. High-grade or border-line deficiency … is very, very common among Spanish-Indian and Mexican families of the Southwest and also among Negroes. Their dullness seems to be racial, or at least inherent in the family stocks from which they come … Children of this group should be segregated into separate classes … They cannot master abstractions but they can often be made into efficient workers … from a eugenic point of view they constitute a grave problem because of their unusually prolific breeding.
There has been considerable work from both hard and social scientists refuting arguments such as Brigham's and Terman's that racial differences in IQ scores are influenced by biology. Critiques of such "hereditarian" hypotheses — arguments that genetics can powerfully explain human character traits and even human social and political problems — cite a lack of evidence and weak statistical analyses.
This critique continues today , with many researchers resistant to and alarmed by research that is still being conducted on race and IQ. But in their darkest moments , IQ tests became a powerful way to exclude and control marginalized communities using empirical and scientific language.
Supporters of eugenic ideologies in the s used IQ tests to identify "idiots", "imbeciles", and the "feebleminded. Compulsory sterilization in the US on the basis of IQ, criminality, or sexual deviance continued formally until the mid s when organizations like the Southern Poverty Law Center began filing lawsuits on behalf of people who had been sterilized.
In , the US Senate voted to compensate living victims of government-sponsored sterilization programs. Debate over what it means to be "intelligent" and whether or not the IQ test is a robust tool of measurement continues to elicit strong and often opposing reactions today. Some researchers say that intelligence is a concept specific to a particular culture. They maintain that it appears differently depending on the context — in the same way that many cultural behaviors would.
For example, burping may be seen as an indicator of enjoyment of a meal or a sign of praise for the host in some cultures and impolite in others. What may be considered intelligent in one environment, therefore, might not in others. For example, knowledge about medicinal herbs is seen as a form of intelligence in certain communities within Africa, but does not correlate with high performance on traditional Western academic intelligence tests.
According to some researchers, the "cultural specificity" of intelligence makes IQ tests biased towards the environments in which they were developed — namely white, Western society. This makes them potentially problematic in culturally diverse settings. The application of the same test among different communities would fail to recognize the different cultural values that shape what each community values as intelligent behavior.
Going even further, given the IQ test's history of being used to further questionable and sometimes racially-motivated beliefs about what different groups of people are capable of, some researchers say such tests cannot objectively and equally measure an individual's intelligence at all. At the same time, there are ongoing efforts to demonstrate how the IQ test can be used to help those very communities who have been most harmed by them in the past.
In , the execution across the US of criminally convicted individuals with intellectual disabilities, who are often assessed using IQ tests, was ruled unconstitutional. This has meant IQ tests have actually prevented individuals from facing "cruel and unusual punishment" in the US court of law. In education, IQ tests may be a more objective way to identify children who could benefit from special education services. This includes programs known as "gifted education" for students who have been identified as exceptionally or highly cognitively able.
Ethnic minority children and those whose parents have a low income, are under-represented in gifted education. The way children are chosen for these programs means that Black and Hispanic students are often overlooked. Some US school districts employ admissions procedures for gifted education programs that rely on teacher observations and referrals or require a family to sign their child up for an IQ test. But research suggests that teacher perceptions and expectations of a student, which can be preconceived, have an impact upon a child's IQ scores , academic achievement , and attitudes and behavior.
That's what Stanford psychologist Lewis Terman wanted us to believe when he introduced the American version of the IQ test in This was quite the opposite intention of the test's original co-inventor, Alfred Binet. But that's a history lesson we'll return to another time.
What Terman had actually come up was a deceptively simple system for ranking academic progress. His Stanford-Binet tests measured many different skills, and then scored the results so that the median was always If you had an IQ score of , it simply meant that half of the test-takers your age had done better and half had done worse. These tests were impressively stable, which meant that, over time, most people ended up in roughly the same place in the pack. If you had tested in the 60th percentile at age 10, chances were pretty good that that you'd test close to the 60th percentile at age 12 and age Far from it.
The reality is that students performing at the top of the class in 4th grade tend to be the same students performing at the top of the class in 12th grade, due to many factors that tend to remain stable in students' lives: family, lifestyle, resources, etc. Being branded with a low IQ at a young age, in other words, is like being born poor.
Due to family circumstances and the mechanisms of society, most people born poor will remain poor throughout their lives. Coming next in this blog: Should kids know their own IQs?
What is IQ? IQ short for "intelligence quotient" is a score derived from a collection of tests which rank academic achievement within a particular age group. What do IQ tests measure? IQ tests measure current academic abilities -- not any sort of fixed, innate intelligence. Collectively, these skills are known as "symbolic logic. They rely heavily upon language and upon a person's skill in defining words, in knowing facts about the world, in finding connections and differences among verbal concepts.
Moreover, the intelligence test reveals little about an indivdual's potential for further growth. IQ problems tend to be "clearly defined, come with all the information needed to solve them, have only a single right answer, which can be reached by only a single method, [and are] disembodied from ordinary experience.
Practical problems , in contrast, tend to require problem recognition and formulation. How are IQ scores determined? This inquiries or question set shaped the foundations for permitting them to potential success in school.
They immediately came to understand those specific children have the option to respond to cutting edge questions that more seasoned kids can answer and the other way around. From these perceptions, Binet proposed the idea of mental age. This was planned to be utilized as a metric to decide on the average intelligence for every group. Not long after, Binet started to build up the very first intelligence test, which is the so-called Binet-Simon scale today; it has become the real basis for the intelligence tests.
In spite of having developed the test, Binet was not convinced that psychometric instruments could be utilized in gauging an inborn and lifelong intelligence of a person.
Binet accepted the reality that intelligence is an expansive subject and that giving a numerical worth was lacking. He also believed that various components impacted knowledge. He likewise accepted that these changed after some time and would just be practically identical to kids with comparable experiences and backgrounds.
Lewis Terman, a psychologist, took the Binet — Simon scale then standardized this for the American participants. It was from the test where Intelligence Quotient was originally coined, and this is composed of one number. More concepts about general intelligence were developed later on.
The modern test focuses on abilities like the ability to use language, spatial perception, memory, mathematical skill, and more. The IQ test was first introduced in But years after that, the test became popular, and even up to these days, this test is widely used. He even quickly convinced many physicians in America to use the test. In the year , Henry Herbert Goddard introduced the IQ test in many different public schools, and by , he tested immigrants at the Ellis land.
The test also gained increased popularity in America and became famous among the early psychologists as well. Though Lewis Terman supplanted Henry Herbert Goddard later on as an authoritative voice in intelligence testing, it was still Goddard who created and established the industry of IQ testing.
0コメント